Guide · Bathroom Renovation
Bathtub Refinishing vs. Liners vs. Replacement
You've got a tired bathtub. Should you refinish it, drop a liner over it, or rip it out and start over? Here's an honest comparison — cost, downtime, durability, and the trade-offs nobody tells you about before you sign a contract.
The short answer
- Refinishing — the right call for most homes. Your existing tub is repaired and bonded with a new factory-grade finish in a single visit, at a fraction of replacement cost.
- Liners — a quick cosmetic fix that hides damage and traps moisture between the liner and the original tub. Most fail within a few years.
- Replacement — only worth the cost and disruption when the tub is structurally beyond repair or you're remodeling the entire bathroom anyway.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | Refinishing (ILS) | Bathtub Liner | Full Replacement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical timeline | Done in a single day | 1–2 days install | 3–7+ days (demo, plumbing, tile, finish) |
| Downtime / tub use | Follow written ILS instructions for the selected coating | Follow the liner manufacturer's written return-to-use instructions | Multiple days out of service |
| Cost vs. replacement | Fraction of replacement | Mid-range | Highest — tub + labor + plumbing + tile |
| Fixes chips & cracks | Yes — repaired before finish | No — covers, doesn't repair | N/A (new tub) |
| Mold / mildew risk | Low — bonded to surface | High — water gets between liner and tub | Low (when sealed properly) |
| Disruption to bathroom | Minimal — no demo | Low — no demo | Major — drywall, tile, plumbing |
| Look & feel | Smooth, factory-grade finish | Plastic shell over old tub | Brand new fixture |
| Warranty | ILS offers a 5-year LIMITED workmanship warranty for fully owner-occupied residential properties only: the homeowner lives there and no part is rented. A 1-year LIMITED workmanship warranty applies to all rental and commercial properties, including owner-occupied homes with any portion rented to tenants. Coverage is for eligible adhesion/delamination, subject to the written warranty terms and exclusions. | Varies by brand | Manufacturer + installer |
Option 1 — Bathtub Refinishing
Refinishing (sometimes called reglazing or resurfacing) means restoring the tub you already own. A professional crew cleans and etches the surface, repairs chips and cracks, primes, and sprays a new finish that bonds permanently to the original substrate. Done right, the result looks and feels like a brand-new tub — without ripping out tile or plumbing.
Our ILS Signature Surface System™ is engineered for residential and commercial bathrooms across Tallahassee, Crawfordville, and North Florida. We use commercial-grade coatings, structural repair compounds, and a controlled spray process. Most projects finish in a single day. Curing and return-to-use depend on the selected coating; follow the written ILS instructions for that coating before using your tub.
Option 2 — Bathtub Liners
A bathtub liner is a custom-molded acrylic or PVC shell that snaps over your existing tub. It's marketed as fast and clean — and it is, on day one. The catch is what happens after.
- Water inevitably seeps between the liner and the original tub through the drain and overflow.
- Trapped moisture grows mold and mildew you can't see, smell, or clean.
- The shell flexes underfoot, cracks at the corners, and lifts at the edges over time.
- It covers damage instead of repairing it — chips and cracks under the liner keep spreading.
Liners can make sense for short-term commercial scenarios where the tub will be ripped out within a few years. For a home you actually live in, refinishing is the better long-term value.
Option 3 — Full Replacement
Replacement is exactly what it sounds like: demo the old tub, repair the framing and subfloor, reroute plumbing if needed, patch tile and drywall, install the new fixture, then re-finish the surrounding wall. It's the right call when the tub is structurally failing — rotted surround, broken substrate, a leaking drain you can't reach — or when you're already gutting the bathroom for a full remodel.
What people underestimate is the total cost of the project, not just the tub. A replacement routinely runs into the thousands once you include demo, disposal, plumbing, new tile, paint, and several days of an unusable bathroom. If your tub is sound but ugly, that's a lot of money and disruption to solve a cosmetic problem.
Which one is right for you?
Choose refinishing if
- The tub is structurally sound but stained, chipped, or dated.
- You want to stay on budget and keep the bathroom intact.
- You need it back in service fast (rental, AirBnB, home sale).
Consider a liner only if
- It's a short-term commercial fix you'll remove in a few years.
- You accept the mold and longevity trade-offs.
- The tub will be replaced soon anyway.
Choose replacement if
- The tub or surround is rotted or structurally damaged.
- You're remodeling the entire bathroom anyway.
- You're changing the tub size, shape, or location.
Frequently asked questions
Is bathtub refinishing better than a liner?
For most homes, yes. Refinishing bonds a new surface directly to the original tub — no gap where water and mold can collect. Liners hide damage and trap moisture behind them.
How much does refinishing cost vs. replacement?
Refinishing typically costs a small fraction of a full replacement once you include demo, plumbing, tile repair, and a new tub. Replacement routinely runs into the thousands and takes days of disruption.
How long does a refinished bathtub last?
With proper care, a professionally refinished ILS tub is built to perform for many years. Lifespan depends on use, cleaning products, and the surface type.
What workmanship warranty applies?
ILS offers a 5-year LIMITED workmanship warranty for fully owner-occupied residential properties only: the homeowner lives there and no part is rented. A 1-year LIMITED workmanship warranty applies to all rental and commercial properties, including owner-occupied homes with any portion rented to tenants. Coverage is for eligible adhesion/delamination, subject to the written warranty terms and exclusions.
Can you refinish a chipped or cracked tub?
Yes. The ILS Signature Surface System™ includes structural chip and crack repair before the new finish is applied, so the tub is restored — not just covered.
Do you refinish more than tubs?
Yes — tubs, showers, tile, countertops, and floor coatings. See the Gallery for real projects.
Not sure which option fits your tub?
Send us a few photos. We'll tell you honestly whether refinishing is the right call — or whether replacement is the better long-term move. No pressure, no obligation.
